Weiner May be Resigning
Posted on June 13th, 2011 in Uncategorized |
…various places are reporting. But should he?
Writing in the Daily Beast, Peter Beinart doesn’t think so:
Here’s one good point:
The current line among talking heads is that he must resign because he’s hurting the Democratic Party, which no longer can focus public attention on the GOP’s efforts to cut Medicare. Talk about a self-fulfilling prophecy. The main reason the Democrats no longer can focus public attention on the GOP’s efforts to cut Medicare, after all, is that talking heads would rather focus on Anthony Weiner’s pecs.
Here’s another:
Other critics say Weiner has shown poor judgment in his private life, which casts doubt about the judgment he’ll show in public life. But there’s no necessary connection between the two. Bill Clinton was privately reckless and publicly cautious; with George W. Bush it was the reverse.
Indeed. George W. Bush never cheated on Laura, so far as we know. But how many hundreds of thousands have died in Iraq because of his moral certitude, his lack of humility?
And I think this is very true:
How many of the pundits mocking Weiner have marriages that could survive the kind of scrutiny they have been giving his? The realization that everyone’s private life is messy and flawed should produce humility and compassion. Instead, pundits enter the public arena as disembodied Olympian figures, entitled to render the harshest of verdicts, secure in the knowledge that no one will ever investigate their most intimate of domains.
Alas, none of this is likely to make any difference. Forget all Weiner’s years of public service, all the fights he waged against Republicans who are actually doing damage to our country. What he did grosses us out. He’s gotta go.
11 Responses
6/13/2011 3:52 pm
B.C.
6/13/2011 3:54 pm
I think Weiner *should* go to rehab. I think he has a significant problem for which he needs professional help. Maybe more stuff will emerge and I’ll change my mind, but I still say: Let the voters decide.
6/13/2011 4:44 pm
I’m still in Italy, RB, where Berlusconi is still Prime Minister, so maybe my expectations are particularly lowered.But I tend to agree. Unless we get something worse than what’s come out so far, I say let his constituency decide — and sure rehab’s always a good idea in such circumstances.
PS Don’t they all lie, all the time, about much more damaging stuff, i.e. why they vote for their lobbyist paymasters against the interests of the rest of us, all the time?
6/13/2011 5:46 pm
B.C.
6/14/2011 11:04 pm
You can take issue with over-coverage or slanted coverage or poor coverage, but a congressman’s bad behavior *is* news. It always has been, and it always will be.
And it’s not irrelevant, methinks, that Weiner has always been a media-hungry congressman. He’s not known among his colleagues as a skilled behind-closed-doors negotiator or as having particular talents for writing or advancing legislation–his value has always been as someone adept at exploiting media coverage for his or his party’s benefit, as a talking-head representative. If you have ill-advised personal habits, you shouldn’t be that sort of congressman. You live by the sword, you die by the sword. If he has any class, he has to resign. Forthwith. We’re not talking about a working-class job here, we are talking about a seat in the House of Representatives. There is not, nor should there be, a high bar for things that make you (unofficially) unfit for office. People have had to forgo or resign political positions for not paying a small portion of their taxes, for hiring an illegal immigrant–in short, for what some may see as lesser ethical or moral lapses. Personally, I am fine with keeping that bar low. And if you have skeletons in your closet like this, you should keep your resignation speech updated and on-hand. Maybe you’ll have to use, maybe not.
6/15/2011 8:19 am
here here!!!!
6/15/2011 2:01 pm
On tech. issues - at least with cell phones we can e-mail/text/blog & all without holding the phone near our ears. Righto?
6/15/2011 2:35 pm
B.C…why do you write your thoughts where names go and sign your name where thoughts go? Just asking. Kinda hard to read your posts and it is a little annoying too.
6/15/2011 3:21 pm
Yes, I’ve wondered that too.
6/15/2011 5:21 pm
On my small screen it says *reply* -then - *name* (first box is large - second box small) o.k.!
6/15/2011 11:55 pm
On a brighter note - cabin fever and/or no car this past month may have caused me to not notice & think the screen looked fine. No -you’re right. (off subject)