Harvard’s $800,000 President
Posted on May 17th, 2009 in Uncategorized |
As the Globe reported yesterday, Drew Faust was paid $775, 043 in salary and benefits for the 2007-2008 fiscal year.
The amount reflects $640,000 in cash compensation, $81,304 in moving and other expenses, and $53,739 in benefits. Harvard provides its president with a home on campus in addition to her compensation.
The Globe immediately reports that this amount is far smaller than some presidents of other universities, referencing David Sargent, the president of Suffolk University, who received $2.8 million last year.
(One wonders if this and other numbers were fed the Globe by the Harvard press office; it feels that way.)
This is something of a bogus example, as no one else was even close to Sargent. What I think would be a fairer question: How much would Faust have done the job for? Are you telling me that if you only paid her $500k, she’d say no? $400k?
The point is not whether Harvard has inflated university president salaries just as other schools have. It’s whether Harvard sets an example of disciplined spending. Clearly, that’s not the case.
Example #2: Larry Summers. The Globe reports…
Former Harvard president Lawrence Summers, who was forced to resign in 2006, was paid $611,226 during his final year as president in 2005-06. Yesterday’s filing showed that Summers received $732,373 for the last fiscal year, 2007-08, during which he was a university professor, Harvard’s highest-ranking professorship. He also has a $1 million mortgage loan from the university.
Summers’s 2007-08 earnings reflect $580,000 in cash compensation, $120,452 in expenses and other allowances, and $31,921 in benefits. His expenses and other allowances include a $62,640 in “special agreement payment,” $52,042 in loan interest subsidies, and $5,500 from the Harvard Kennedy School.
I think it’s the case that Summers didn’t teach a class at Harvard last year. What exactly was he being paid for? Why is Harvard paying him $120,000 in expenses? We can assume that Summers’ travel was paid for by the banks who lavished millions upon him to buy influence with the Obama administration. How exactly did Summers rack up $120k in expenses?
Here’s a story for a Crimson reporter to do: Investigate the institution of the University Professor. Look at the combined salaries of those professors, and then see how productive those professors are—in any given year, how many courses do they teach? How many books do they publish?
I’ll guarantee you, it’s a big story. And in a time of “reshaping,” nothing should be sacred.
I understand that Drew Faust meets regularly with the Crimson. (Maybe not now, that it’s almost Commencement time.)
How about asking Faust these questions:
1) Did you receive a raise from your 2007-2008 salary? Will you instead volunteer to accept a pay cut for the 2008-2009 fiscal year? Will your pay cut be at least 25%, the amount funds for Harvard houses are being cut?
2) Why is Larry Summers being paid more than you? Is he continuing to receive salary from Harvard, even in the form of deferred compensation, even though he no longer works at the university?
And for the members of SLAM, here’s a piece of rhetoric for you: While Harvard cuts hot breakfast for students, Drew Faust is making millions and living in a mansion.
What do you bet they’re still serving hot breakfasts at the president’s house?
14 Responses
5/17/2009 8:05 am
Summers did co-teach a class last year, co-offered by the econ dept and the kennedy school:
Economics 1400/ITF-225 The Contents of Globalization: Issues, Actors, and Decisions
Catalog Number: 5906
Lawrence H. Summers and Lant Pritchett (Kennedy School)
5/17/2009 8:27 am
Could you define “co-teach” in this context?
5/17/2009 8:36 am
What are you looking for? Co-teaching is co-teaching. Sometimes Summers gave the lecture and sometimes Pritchett did. I didn’t take the class but have sat in it for a few times. I would say Summers was very invested in the class.
5/17/2009 8:46 am
Anybody know what a $62K “special agreement payment” is? Just something Harvard agreed to pay, above and beyond salary and expenses, for some unstated reason?
As for the $120K expenses, the corresponding Globe story from two years ago, by Marcella Bombardieri, had more detail. Probably some of these items were simply guaranteed to continue. I wonder for how long. (”Loan interest subsidies”? Another unfamiliar perk.)
In addition to his regular compensation last year, he received $102,779 for housing outside Cambridge, legal expenses, personal travel, loan interest subsidies, and retirement gifts. Part of the money helped pay for his apartment in Washington, D.C., where his children live.
5/17/2009 9:04 am
I’m just curious what Summers is being paid for, that’s all, Weiqi. $700k for co-teaching one course? Nice work if you can get it.
5/17/2009 9:42 am
Rubin was the sole Corporation member who dragged his feet on ousting Summers toward the end. Summers contratct, as egregious as it is, was the price for bringing Rubin around. However, Houghton and Rothenberg eventually supported the contract. The fact they had to hold their noses does not excuse them from wasting University assets. Once again this Summers severance saga points to a rotten governance structure. Another view, equally valid, is the governance structure is just fine; it is that the members have demonstrated a complete lack of skills necessary to hold their jobs.
5/17/2009 11:46 am
I was just clarifying a fact that I think you should correct. That at least explains “5,500 from the Harvard Kennedy School” and part of other payment. “$700k for co-teaching one course”? Of course not. In most cases teaching is not directly linked with payment. Some profs don’t teach a single class. Others, like Lamont University Professor Amartya Sen, also taught only one class last year. If you can compare their payment before singling out Summers’ case, it would be more useful.
Also, regarding your speculation that “this and other numbers were fed the Globe by the Harvard press office,” the payment of Suffolk’s President was featured in the Chronicle of Higher Education last year (The Globe http://chronicle.com/weekly/v55/i13/13b00501.htm.) It was the high compensation among all universities in the nation, so it’s more than natural to draw the comparison.
5/17/2009 11:48 am
* … the HIGHEST compensation …
5/17/2009 11:58 am
Weigi–first, I know the numbers for Suffolk’s president are public. All non-profits have to list the compensation of their highest paid officers. My point was that I could see someone at Harvard telling the Globe, “Hey, by way of comparison, you should look at….” And no, it’s not natural to draw a comparison with an exceptional example. A better example would have been Summers in his first full year as president, in which he received substantially less than Faust did.
As to your first point: If Summers is receiving $5500 for co-teaching one course, what, pray tell, is he getting the other $695k or so for?
My point was casually written, but it was to the effect of, Harvard is paying Larry Summers about $700, 000 a year, and in return he is co-teaching one course.
5/17/2009 12:11 pm
How do you rack up 81K in moving expenses when you have no furniture of your own? That’s a lot of scrambled eggs and sausages.
5/17/2009 7:02 pm
Amazing what DF is making, given that almost noone thinks she is a presence at Harvard, or can name anything significant she is doing.
5/17/2009 9:33 pm
In what ways does Harvard resemble the land of oz?
The Wizard is one of the characters in The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. Unseen for most of the novel, he is the ruler of the Land of Oz and highly venerated by his subjects. Believing he is the only man capable of solving their problems, Dorothy Gale and her friends travel to the Emerald City, the capital of Oz, to meet him. Oz is very reluctant to meet them, but eventually they are granted an audience. Every time the Wizard appears in a different form, once as a giant head, once as a beautiful fairy, once as ball of fire, and once as a horrible monster.
Eventually, it is revealed that Oz is actually none of these things, but rather an ordinary, man from Omaha who has been using a lot of elaborate magic tricks and props to make himself seem “great and powerful.” Working as a magician for a circus, he wrote OZ on the side of his hot air balloon for promotional purposes. One day his balloon sailed into the Land of Oz, and found himself worshipped as a great sorcerer. As Oz had no leadership at the time, he became Supreme Ruler of the kingdom, and did his best to sustain the myth.
He leaves Oz at the end of the novel, again in a hot air balloon. After the Wizard’s departure, the Scarecrow is briefly enthroned, until the rightful hereditary ruler of Oz, Princess Ozma, is freed from the witch Mombi at the end of The Marvelous Land of Oz.
In a later Oz book, Oz explains that his real name is Oscar Zoroaster Phadrig Isaac Norman Henkel Emmannuel Ambroise Diggs. To shorten this name, he used only his initials (O.Z.P.I.N.H.E.A.D.), but since they spell out the word “pinhead”, he shortened his name further and called himself “Oz”.
In The Marvelous Land of Oz, the Wizard is described as having usurped the throne of King Pastoria and handed over the baby princess to Mombi. This did not please the readers, and in Ozma of Oz, although the character did not appear, Baum described Ozma’s abduction without including the Wizard as part of it.[2]
5/18/2009 9:07 am
Investigative reporting at its best:
http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=528243
5/18/2009 4:42 pm
The pain is not being shared. Salary freezes hurt those at the bottom much more than they do those who are earning 500K plus.